Category Archives: nonmonogamy

Casual/Casual +

I was curious what the fella’s on a certain community site would say about the topic of casual sex.  I’m mildly surprised that most people don’t consider something casual sex unless it is entirely anonymous and you never speak.  Really?  Ok, I guess I don’t want actual casual sex then.  Wow.  I like to find profiles on the web and exchange a few emails.  Then meet up with a thin pretense of something to do for about an hour.  Then we can go back to your place.  I may or may not ever feel the need to talk to you after that but I will have fond feelings for you.  Some of these turn into friendships, most don’t.  I don’t mind in the slightest.

Really?  That’s not casual?  Wow.  Once again, I need a new word.  Because even saying NSA (no strings attached) isn’t quite what I mean.  And it’s not really friends with benefits because I don’t think we need to be friends.  Fuckbuddy implies we are buddies.  We aren’t.  You are a stranger on the internet.  A perfectly nice one.  One I obviously find attractive (this is usually a combination of looks, intelligence, and ‘feels like tribe’) so what is that?

I like running into former lovers.  I like the smile I get.  I like the soft brush of the arm as they acknowledge that they know how to touch me.  If I don’t litter my lovers all over the valley, how can I have that experience?

One of the problems with polyamory

I don’t know if other people sit around in their off-time listening to songs and trying to place them onto various relationships.  Particularly, today I am listening to Adele’s Someone Like You.  The way she talks about the song in this video is striking.  It has dramatically altered my hearing of the song.

I miss Steve and Tom.  I think I would be able to be the kind of person Steve could be friends now.  I think I have changed my reactions to some of our patterns.  I didn’t like how I treated Steve, but I liked Steve.  I would have broken him if I had stayed with him.  Instead I ran away.  I didn’t just break off dating him.  I stopped going any place he might be.  I avoided his friends like the plague.  Anyone who knew us both lost me after the break up.

I walked away from my life.  I broke all ties.  I changed my major in college.  I dropped out of college.  I broke up with Steve just a few months before our wedding and then I evaporated like a drop of water.  But there were a lot of reasons I wanted to marry him, you know?  He was a really amazing person.  I miss him.  I miss the things he brought into my life.  I don’t want to have sex with him, that part didn’t work well for me.  But I miss him being my close friend.  I dated him before I had ever told anyone the full story of my abuse.  Before I was out publicly as a rape survivor.  I could still name every single person I had ever had sexual contact with.  I had two lists.  One of girls, which was very long.  I didn’t tell people about that list.  And the boys, which was long but not frightening because I don’t count my rapists.  Oh wait, there was a third list in my head–the rapists.  I could still count my positive boy-sex experiences on my fingers with Steve.  Steve was the first boy who ever gave me an actual orgasm. I faked it before that.  Uhm, sorry people from high school.

I miss Steve a lot.  He was passionate about things the way Noah is.  I love basking in that kind of joy in the simple act of attaining knowledge.  Steve liked to learn.  He was inspiring to be around.  He isn’t book smart, and it was by choice.  He came from a highly educated family.  He was a self-didact though.  He knew how to do an amazing array of things.  And if he didn’t know how to do something he would figure out how to learn.  Nothing daunted him.  I miss that.  I didn’t know how to deal with it when I was 18.  I didn’t know how to explain to him that things were harder for me than him because I didn’t have this loving background telling me I could accomplish things, I had to move slower than him sometimes.

Enh, I don’t remember the particulars well enough to analyze it.  Whatever.  That’s not the point.  I would really like to know what kind of man he has become.  I’m pretty sure I was right back then when I knew that I wouldn’t enjoy living with him long-term.  But I think I could be his friend now.  I think I would know how to listen to his interests without bashing him over the head with my issues.

I ran from Steve to Tom.  In a straight line.  Jumping on a few nice people along the way.  I was 18 and living with a lonely old lady who wanted company and I wanted to be surfing the internet looking for sex.  As soon as I became involved with him I started using his house as a base.  I was there a lot when he was at work because I didn’t have anywhere else to be.  His internet was paid for, he didn’t seem to care.

I’m not sure he understood how much time I was there.  How much time I spent auditioning a life in that house before our relationship got all that serious.  I picked him.  I wanted him.  I didn’t have to look around the local community for more than three months before I was damn sure he was the only person in that lot I wanted to seriously pursue.  And I did.  And on our first date he told me that he was looking for the One.  The One he would marry and have children with.

I am not going to get into it much right now.  That’s too big of a story.  I can’t do that today.  I can’t write it down today.  But I can sit here and listen to Adele sing.  And I cry.  Because I can’t write that story yet.  I am in the middle of another one.

I date Puppy because I was trying to replace Tom.  Puppy was the most abusive relationship I have had as an adult.  If he had not ended it when he did I think he would have hit me.  He was escalating in his violent displays when I didn’t react how he wanted.  I wasn’t good enough for him.  His family hated me and picking me would have meant ostracizing his family.  Or having to have relationships with them that involved no discussion of his life with me.  He didn’t think I was worth it.  He was a nasty piece of shit to me trying to get me to break up with him.  When my response was to cry for a while then try to problem solve he freaked out.  He wanted me to do something nasty so he had justification for his behavior.  I feel like my relationship with Puppy absolves me of my guilt for treating Steve so badly.  I learned how to control that anger.  I’m really sorry I fucked up like that at 18.  But I learned.  I changed.  Some people never do.  I’m proud of myself.

I am too angry with Noah.  Almost none of it is directed at him.  I’m not angry because of anything related to Noah.  I’m just angry.  At so many stupid things I remember and can’t let go of.  So many things that I’m trying to write down and be done with.  Puppy left me with a nasty email about how I will end up bitter and alone.  Just. Like. His. Mother.  Yeah, that’s about me?  I think not.

I don’t need to feel bad for my part in that any more.  That was a shitty relationship.  I don’t think it escalated to abuse but it wanted to.  It didn’t partially because I learned to control my temper.  That’s pretty cool.  I needed to do that.  It was essential in helping me be a good teacher.  And oh boy is it more important as a mother.  I’m sorry I hurt Steve.  But I forgive myself.  I had good reasons to be angry.  The more of this book I write the more I understand why people in authority positions widen their eyes when I tell my stories.  I should be exploding with anger.  I should be standing on top of a tall building with a machine gun taking my rage out on all of humanity.  That’s what a wounded animal as smart as me would do.

For all that people tell me I’m an angry person, I’m not.  Not really.  I was.  I’m sad.  I’m afraid.  Writing my story down all in one block and thinking about how many years of my life I have spent alone in a room is hard.  I don’t know how to have a real live actual family.  I’m scared.

I dated Tom for more years than I lived with my brother Jimmy after the age of three.  I lived with Tom for almost as many years as I lived with Tommy.  We were very close.  But he could never decide if I was really worth so much effort.  He wasn’t interested in getting married and having kids with me.  I think that given his life priorities, he made the right decision.  I’m not the right kind of girl for him.  And that still hurts.  I wanted to be.  I tried so hard to be what I thought he wanted.  Oh so many things I want to say.  They come over me in waves, these memories.

But I don’t think I can be friends with Tom.  We were too much.  I want too much.  I miss too much.  I want too much of him still.  I don’t know if anything could ever actually work.  I’m not going to let myself think about it.  I can’t.  I ran away.  I slammed the door on that part of my life pretty hard.  It has taken many years for me to figure out that some people in that community can be my friends because they aren’t actually interested in being his friend.  I didn’t have to ask them to pick a side!  They came pre-picked!  I’m a shallow piece of shit.

No, I have problems with boundaries.  I don’t think I would be able to have any if I spent extended time with Tom.  Once again, I don’t know that it is even sex I want.  I want to crawl back into his head.  I want to once again hear him tell me about the most intense parts of himself.  I want to watch him enjoy driving.  I want to be tied up.  I wouldn’t mind it being non-sexual.  I miss being enjoyed for just being there to look at.  That’s something that’s hard to communicate about objectification.  It means that someone doesn’t have to know all of my dirty stupid little secrets, they can enjoy looking at me.  Maybe I am beautiful.

Maybe if I write about what I really miss in enough detail I can find a way to get those specific needs met in other ways.  It’s worth a try.  But not today.  Maybe someday I will find someone like Tom.  Maybe I will be able to figure it out.

Daydreaming is weird.  Because I have these thoughts.  I have them a lot when I’m driving.  Polyamory means that I can have my Bridges of Madison County track in the back of my brain and know that I am not being disloyal to the people in front of me.

I feel sad that Noah does the same thing.  I don’t know that he does it exactly the same way I do.  But he has similar yearnings to not feel like doors are closed.  There is one girl he is kind of bitter about.  I handled it badly.  He really was falling in love.  It felt like watching my chance at stable happiness leave every time he went on a date.  I don’t trust that anyone else can love more than one person at a time.  My family couldn’t do that.  One kid at a time was “special” and whoever wasn’t in the center… well… when my brothers weren’t at the center it was because they weren’t there.  Sometimes when my mother and I lived alone somewhere I was the center.  That was wonderful.  Anytime there was anyone else around I was ignored.  She had missed those kids the whole time she had me.  She had talked about that endlessly.  She didn’t talk about me in glowing terms the way she did them.  She didn’t idealize me.  She lived with me.

I don’t want to be that for Noah.  I’m scared.  It is so hard to trust him.  It is so hard to trust anyone.  There is no one else in the world I would even bother to try to trust like I trust Noah.  I can’t.  I’m not capable.  And that hurts.  Once people have been close to me like that, if they fuck up even slightly then I have to completely and totally evaporate from their lives.  I can’t handle being demoted.  When Noah starts paying attention to someone else I feel demoted.  I go from being the wife to being part of the harem.  Now I’m “one of Noah’s girls”.  I feel disposable.  It’s not true.  I know Noah doesn’t feel that way.  Not even slightly.  But that’s what I feel.

You know.  Once I get the problem nailed down this specifically it’s time to talk to the California Mindfucker.  I like NLP.  It’s a convenient tool.  I keep hitting this same wall.  And it’s not rational.  I can explain it 50 more times and they will all come down to the same thing.  I want to change my irrational feelings and I’m not managing on my own.  There are tricks for that.

Someone like you

Writing about my family makes me think about every romantic relationship I’ve ever had.  How and where was I looking for Daddy?  It’s interesting that I don’t like dating tall men.  If they are over 6′ I’m probably not interested.  My father was 6’7″.  My mom was 5’2″.  I had one date with a guy who was 6’10” and that was too much for me.  I couldn’t deal with that.  It felt really disgusting and inappropriate.  Which is kind of a strong reaction to an otherwise really nice guy.

I forgot something when I went looking for an affair.  I forgot that I want people who give me a lot of slack and a lot of space around my “issues”.  I want people who are already broken in because I don’t know how to tell the story piecemeal any more.  I lost that because of Noah.  Noah can handle such ridiculous intensity from me that I don’t know how to tone it down for other people.  Noah can handle me sobbing and screaming and beating on pillows in the middle of an otherwise normal conversation and transition straight into sex when I want it.  I’m pretty sure I have scared Noah or made him feel put-off at some point, but I’d be damned if I could remember when.  Whatever I throw at that man, he just rolls with it.

I forgot how special that is.  I’ve been alone at home with Noah for years growing ever more entwined.  I can use increasingly terse shorthand and he knows these elaborate stories.  After Noah talking to a new person is hard.  It feels frustrating because I don’t know how to explain things in easily digestible chunks anymore.  Now I want to hurry up and finish the book so I can hand them the whole story in advance and say, “Either you can handle this or you can’t.”  That’s not how normal relationships go though.

Last night I went to sleep with my muse.  When I woke up I came over to Daddy’s house.  I haven’t had sex with Daddy in… six?  seven? years.  It’s been a while.  It was similar to and different from what I remember.  I feel like we make fewer assumptions now.  He has so many years of being a close friend that there isn’t much I can’t say to him.  I can be as stupidly blunt and tactless as I am without feeling like it’s going to alienate him.  If he was going to be alienated, it probably would have happened when I dumped him seven years ago.  Instead he remained one of my close friends.  There have been many times over the years when I have shown up at his house at odd hours and he has held me while I cry.

It’s weird sitting in his house now.  I’m killing time until I go to therapy.  He’s working.  It feels comfortable and uncomfortable.  This isn’t where he lived when we dated.  Somehow that’s a good thing.  I’m kind of sad his housemate hasn’t come out of her room.  She is another former lover.  I haven’t seen her much in years and I miss her.  She is one of the few women I’ve had one on one sex with in the last ten years.  I kind of hope I get to give her a hug before I leave.  She came out!  I got my hug.  Yay.

This feels like visiting a part of me I left behind.  These are people from my old life.  In some ways this is like walking into a weird old movie and in other ways it feels like getting to relax.  I have nothing to prove.  I don’t need to show them who I am.  They know already.  If I start crying in the middle of breakfast fairly randomly I don’t have to worry about that being a deal breaker.  I’m not going to risk rejection in this house.  Not unless I do something extraordinarily egregious, which I can’t imagine doing.  This is nice.

I’ve been sitting here thinking about similarities and differences among the men who have tried to handle me.  I do best with men who are able to be still and silent while my emotions rage.  It’s hard on them.  I know.  It’s hard not to take it personally when I’m freaking out.  Noah handles this better than anyone ever has.  He listens really intently to what I am saying and to what I am not saying.  He’s good at ignoring the hyperbole and figuring out why I am actually upset.  He has spent so much time listening intently to me that he knows before I do when I am avoiding a point to get upset about something standing next to it.

Daddy doesn’t make the same leaps.  But he listens.  He stays present.  He has yet to be scared off by anything I’ve told him.  This is why people are poly.  Because there is more than one person who can be present with me.  It’s hard to have the same reservoir of trust with a “friend”.  It’s a different kind of trust and support.  After more than seven years he has certainly earned my trust.  It’s neat finding out what it is like to evolve in a relationship.  I’m doing it with Noah.  I’m trying to do it with Sarah.  I’m trying to do it with Daddy.  I wonder what my life will look like in five years.

Daddy told me that it’s been neat watching me grow up.  He doesn’t think I would have been able to be a mother when we met.  I was still too hair trigger on leaving.  He’s probably right.  It’s really nice knowing that he can look at me and see that I’m not perfect, but I’m still pretty good.  I’m still worth keeping around.  Because he loves me.  Even though I’ve hurt him.  Even though I feel like an unending river of fucking up.

This is so confusing.

Hypocrisy

Last night I told Noah that I am willing to have sex every day, even on days I’m not into it, in exchange for him giving me the courtesy of the public lie that I am interesting enough to be enough for him when we are out together.  That’s the kind of thing that makes him furrow his brow and take a long deep breath.  It always looks like I’ve kicked him.  I probably did.

Everyone makes a different kind of peace with nonmonogamy.  Mine is tattered and barely existant.  I wish I didn’t have this deep compulsion to sleep with other people so that I could declare it off limits for Noah.  But I do.  This really sucks.  He wouldn’t be happy about me trying to require monogamy, but he’d deal.  He took his marriage vows seriously.  I don’t think I can give monogamy.  I think I would become obsessed with cheating.  I think that my periodic times when I am driven to obsessively check okcupid (even though it’s just about a dead end at this point) would be a problem if I was monogamous.  It would feel different.

As a nonmonogamous person I’m allowed the freedom to think about looking pretty much any time.  That’s fun.  That lets me think about myself as a sexually available person and that is linked to all kinds of fun energy.  I like that part of me a lot.  NRE just isn’t available in long term batches.  I think Noah and I have a more affectionate than average marriage… it’s not NRE.  It’s not new-person-hot-sex.  It’s different.  There is a kind of being seen I get from making sex work with new people.  It’s important to me.

It’s important to Noah too.  Fuck him.  Jerk.  Meaniehead.  He doesn’t want me.  I am not enough.  This is tinged because I can see him raising his eyebrow at me.  NO IT DOESN’T MEAN THAT ABOUT YOU, JUST ME I AM THE ONLY INFERIOR ONE IN THIS RELATIONSHIP.  ahem.  Emotions are really stupid.

All of this comes down to a horrible hypocrisy on my part.  One I’m not sure how to resolve in myself.  I feel like part of my current issue is that I don’t like seeing Noah play with other people unless I was actively involved from the get go and never walk away.  I can’t walk up on Noah playing.  It makes my stomach flip flop and I want to cry.  I hate it.  He’s mine.  He’s the only person on the whole fucking planet who is mine and how dare someone else touch him.

And I hate that my awesome, wonderful husband wants to make other women fall in love with him.  Because he does.  I really kind of hate him for that.  It hurts.  He’s not as into the fuck and run as I am.  He can do it when I’m putting that requirement on him, but it’s not his preference.

I am going to fall apart when he finds someone.  This is going to be awful.  I don’t know how I will handle this.  I really kind of hate nonmonogamy.  I feel bad for the women who have to deal with me in order to get Noah.  I feel like a horrible partner.  I feel like a bitch.  Like I just suck at doing this.  I don’t know that I can be nice to someone Noah falls for and that’s not ok.

I’m borrowing trouble.  I have a little less than four years till he’s allowed to go after that kind of thing.  In the mean time I think he should start going to parties to hunt alone.  It’s not don’t ask don’t tell.  I just don’t want to watch.

My issues with our house.

Alternatively titled “Noah’s House of Whores” but I thought it would be pretty fucked up to have that be the URL.  I have a lot of deep seated issues around my sexuality.  I am increasingly comfortable referring to myself as a whore.  I can’t tell if this is a sign of my lowering or raising self esteem.  Well, at least if I’m a whore I’m a damn good one.  I picked a very specific flavor of being a whore.  Yes, yes, he married me.  That “sanctifies” the sex and justifies him supporting me forever just because.  Only that’s not true.  There has to be a balance or relationships don’t work.

I think Noah would be capable of turning off his voracious need for sex if I required him to.  I think he would become a shadow of himself.  I don’t want to break him.  That’s not why I married him.  I want to see what he can do.  I knew that it was going to be an E ticket ride.  Noah married me because he likes my extremes.  My willingness to communicate.

I chose this relationship because it felt right.  Because this meets my needs.  It bothers me that I need to have a partner I can think about the way I think about Noah sometimes.  To back up, I never wanted to live in this house.  To me places kind of absorb the energy of the people in them.  Noah has dated a lot of women here.  I saw a fair bit of it.  I know even more of the women who came and went.  I’m actually on good terms with the majority of them.  (Uhm, apologies for referring all of you as whores–it’s about me, not about you.)

When I am out with someone I tend to feel enormously bad if they pay attention to someone else.  If I come back from the bathroom and Noah is cuddling someone else?  I feel like I’m about to vomit.  It’s instant and visceral.  I have this flash of terror I knew he would stop wanting me soon.  He was just waiting until I stepped away to show it.  It’s even worse if he keeps his arm casually around said other woman and beckons me closer.  Because then it’s not that he doesn’t want me.  It’s that I’m not special enough to be interesting by myself.  I’m better with a friend.  Anyone improves the experience.  The writing over the past few days has been about my dad and how he treated me when I was five and under.

I don’t like the parallels about how I picked a partner who wants me to be an enthusiastic whore with no ability to say no to sex.  Very uncomfortable feeling.  I’m supposed to be available to anyone and everyone at a whim.

This is not true of course.  This isn’t how Noah feels.  But it’s how I feel.  This is my internal dialogue.  This is the pressure I put on myself.  I feel like it is my duty to be sexually available, even if I don’t want to.  Even if I’m not enjoying the sex.  Especially if the person wants to hurt me.  I don’t like the fact that pain makes me orgasm when gentle touching does not.  I don’t appreciate the fact that my husband doing any amount of vanilla foreplay can’t do much of anything for me.  But pain does.  That’s part of why I feel like a whore.  My sexuality has to involve degradation and pain or it doesn’t count as sex.  It really sucks.

That’s hyperbole.  But it’s more true than not.  I have to be objectified.  I have to be used to get someone else off or I feel like I have failed at what I am obligated to do during sex.  Thing is, my husband doesn’t really like that I need to feel that way.  For all that Noah has done some heinous shit to me, he doesn’t want to be that person full time.  He doesn’t want to make me feel bad about myself daily.

So how do we handle sex?  Gingerly.  In ways that feel fairly unsatisfying sometimes.  I feel dirty and used.  He feels sad and like he is hurting me.  But he isn’t.  It would be much worse if he stopped having sex with me.  I get most of my touch needs met through sex and massage.  I can only afford to pay for so much massage.  I can’t handle having people touch me non-sexually most of the time.  I don’t know how to react.  I panic.  I feel scared.  I don’t know what they want from me and my impulse is to run as far and as fast as I can.

Nonmonogamy makes this all more complicated.  Noah sleeping with other people reminds me that my hooha is not glittery.  I have to be honest and say I’m bitter.  I feel let down.  Me sleeping with other people reminds me that I’m not good at following rules or bonding or doing the things people are supposed to do in relationships.  Like be faithful.  I suck at that.  I get antsy and then I feel absolutely compulsive about finding a new partner.  There is some gaping need I have and I know no other way to fill it.  I need that attention.

God I resent the shit out of Noah needing it too.  Then I feel like an asshole hypocrite.  He’s supposed to just know that me being nonmonogamous is because I am defective and icki and kind of ignore it and be above such base needs.  Or something.  I’m so emotionally raw we shouldn’t make any long-term decisions.  I don’t know what I want.

I know it has been true for a long time that sex always feels taboo and like I’m doing something bad.  I wish that would change.